In short
We checked three matchmakers serving Auckland on 21 November 2026, Two publish prices: Two's Company $650 for four introductions and Shortlist $460 for three. Compatico quotes privately. New Zealand has no law written for dating agencies. DatingAgency.com is not an agency.
| Agencies listed | 3, each checked on its own website |
|---|---|
| Publishing a price | 2 of 3 |
| Lowest price per introduction | About $153 (Shortlist's three-introduction package) |
| Dating agency law | None specific; the Consumer Guarantees Act applies |
| Checked on | 21 November 2026 |
Auckland has a small but varied set of matchmakers: a long-running one-to-one agency, a newer pay-per-introduction service and a premium membership aimed at older professionals. Unusually, two of the three publish prices: $175 for a single introduction, up to $650 for four.
Everything below comes from each firm's own website, checked on the date shown, and its own documents take precedence over our summary. No listing is paid for and none carries an affiliate link.
Who's working in Auckland right now
Two's Company (Auckland and Wellington, since 2003)
A one-to-one matchmaking agency run by Sasha Madarasz, working with singles in Auckland and Wellington from their mid-20s to early 80s. It starts with a relaxed chat and tells you whether it has suitable matches before you decide to join. It publishes one fee: $650 including GST, which its FAQ says covers your profile and four personal introductions, with no subscription or expiry and "a fair refund policy" set out in the contract. It writes your profile within two working days, aims to send your first match within three weeks, and follows up after every first date. Its press page says it doesn't use photos: you receive a written profile of each potential match.
Shortlist (New Zealand-wide)
A newer, human-led matchmaking service that says it focuses on New Zealand's major regions. Every application is personally reviewed, and accepted applicants have a short one-to-one call in which the team confirms their ID. Its published packages are an Intro package of three introductions for $460 including GST and a single By Request introduction for $175. Unused introductions don't expire, you can pause for up to six months, and if it hasn't made an introduction within 12 months it says it returns half your package fee.
Compatico (Auckland-founded, 30-plus)
A premium matchmaking and events service founded by businesswoman Theresa Gattung, for people aged 30 and over (its earlier pages said 40-plus). It sells two main memberships: Platinum "Match Me", with a personally assigned matchmaker, face-to-face consultations and a professional photoshoot, and Gold "Matchable", which puts you in its private pool to be selected for matches and gives you access to events. Its services page didn't show membership prices when we read it, so ask for the current fee for each. Its FAQ says new members arrange a Ministry of Justice criminal record check and sign a membership agreement. Platinum members are matched first each month. Its home page was advertising 20% off memberships when we checked.
Prices side by side
| Agency | Published price | What it says instead | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Two's Company | $650 including GST | Profile plus four personal introductions; no expiry | 21 Nov 2026 |
| Shortlist | $460 for three introductions; $175 for one | Half the fee back if no introduction within 12 months | 21 Nov 2026 |
| Compatico | Not shown on the pages we read | Gold: in the pool to be selected, plus events. Platinum: a matchmaker working for you | 21 Nov 2026 |
Compare the cost per introduction, not just the headline price. At $650 for four, Two's Company works out at about $163 each; Shortlist's Intro package at about $153 each. Compatico's memberships don't promise a number of introductions on the pages we read, so ask for the price and how many introductions members typically receive in a year.
What New Zealand law says
We found no licensing scheme or law written for dating agencies in New Zealand, so two general laws do the work:
- The Consumer Guarantees Act applies automatically to services you buy for personal use. The service must be carried out with reasonable care and skill, be fit for the purpose you explained, and be done within a reasonable time. If you told the agency you wanted introductions in a certain age range or area and it took you on, write that into the agreement or confirm it by email.
- If the agency approached you uninvited, at home, at work or by phone, for $100 or more, the Fair Trading Act gives you five working days to cancel for any reason, with a full refund. No copy of that agreement? You can cancel at any time.
- If you contacted the agency yourself, which is how most people start, the contract's own cancellation and refund terms apply, alongside the guarantees above.
If you and the agency can't agree, the government's consumer service says to use an industry disputes scheme where one exists, and otherwise the Disputes Tribunal. Our guide to dating agencies in New Zealand explains each of these. We're not lawyers, so take advice if a large sum is at stake.
How each one checks the people you'll meet
- Two's Company. Meets each client for a first conversation before introductions; ask whether it checks ID.
- Shortlist. Reviews every application personally and confirms each person's ID on a one-to-one call.
- Compatico. Asks new members to arrange a Ministry of Justice criminal record check and sign a membership agreement.
An ID check confirms who someone is. It doesn't confirm that everything they told the agency is true. Our guide to how agencies vet members explains what to ask.
What to ask at your first consultation
Take these to any matchmaker in Auckland, and ask for the answers in writing:
- What is the full fee, including taxes, and what does each package include?
- How many introductions will I get, over what period, and does a match I decline count as one?
- Are my matches paying clients, people in your free database, or people you headhunt?
- How many current members fit what I'm looking for, and how far away do they live?
- What checks do you run on matches: ID, criminal records, relationship status?
- Can I pause my membership, and what happens if you run out of suitable people?
- How do I cancel, and what would I get back?
Our full list of questions has more, and warning signs when choosing an agency covers the pressure tactics to walk away from.
When a agency isn't the answer
A matchmaker makes most sense if you're short of time, want people screened before you meet them, and can afford to lose the fee if it doesn't work out. It makes less sense on a tight budget, or if you'd rather see who's out there yourself. Be cautious with anyone who presses you to sign at the first meeting, suggests financing the fee, or won't let you take the contract home. Is a matchmaker worth it? walks through the decision.
If something goes wrong
Start with the agency, in writing, then escalate.
| Problem | Where to go |
|---|---|
| The agency won't cancel or refund | Write to it citing your contract and the Consumer Guarantees Act; if you can't agree, the Disputes Tribunal |
| You paid by card and the service wasn't provided | Your card provider: ask about a chargeback |
| An introduction asks you for money | Don't pay; tell the agency, contact your bank straight away, and report it to Netsafe and the Police |
| You feel unsafe | Leave, and call 111 in an emergency or 105 otherwise |
Our own online service, listed separately
DatingAgency.com is not one of the services above. We run an online dating service where you do the searching yourself: nobody interviews members or picks matches. Joining, making a profile and browsing are free; reading and replying to messages needs a paid membership that renews until you cancel. Profiles are shared with partner sites in the same network, and what members write about themselves isn't checked. How our service works and our prices give the details, and the same safety advice applies.
Join Dating Agency free
Free to join and browse. Reading and replying to messages is paid.
Questions people ask
How much does a matchmaker cost in Auckland?
Two of the three publish prices. Two's Company charges $650 including GST for four introductions, and Shortlist $460 for three or $175 for one. Compatico didn't show membership prices on the pages we read. Compare the cost per introduction and what happens if none are made.
Can I cancel a dating agency contract in New Zealand?
If the agency approached you uninvited for $100 or more, you have five working days to cancel with a full refund. If you contacted it yourself, the contract's own terms apply, alongside the Consumer Guarantees Act's standards for the service.
Do Auckland matchmakers check who they introduce?
Shortlist says it confirms each person's ID on a call, and Compatico asks members for a Ministry of Justice criminal record check. Two's Company meets each client first. Ask each exactly what it checks.
What is the best matchmaker in Auckland?
We don't rank matchmakers: nobody can test them fairly without being a client of each. Compare them on who is in their network, how they screen people, what counts as an introduction, the full fee and the cancellation terms, and get each answer in writing.
Is DatingAgency.com a dating agency?
No. We are not an agency and nobody here picks matches. Our online dating service is listed separately below, labelled as ours.
Keep reading
- Dating agencies and matchmakers in Belfast and Northern IrelandIntroduction services covering Belfast compared from their own websites: prices, vetting and contract terms.
- Dating agencies and matchmakers in Birmingham and the West MidlandsFour services covering Birmingham and the West Midlands compared from their own websites: prices, vetting and contract terms.
- Matchmakers and dating agencies in BostonSeven matchmakers covering Boston compared from their own websites, with what Massachusetts consumer law covers.
- Dating agencies and matchmakers in Brighton, Hove and SussexIntroduction services covering Brighton compared from their own websites: prices, vetting and contract terms.
Sources
- Home page, Two's Company (checked 21 November 2026)
- FAQ, Two's Company (checked 21 November 2026)
- Fees, Two's Company (checked 21 November 2026)
- Press, Two's Company (checked 21 November 2026)
- How it works, Shortlist (checked 21 November 2026)
- Packages, Shortlist (checked 21 November 2026)
- Home page, Compatico (checked 21 November 2026)
- Our services, Compatico (checked 21 November 2026)
- About us and FAQ, Compatico (checked 21 November 2026)
- Poor quality or incomplete work, Consumer Protection (Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment)
- Telemarketing and door-to-door sales, Consumer Protection
- Door-to-door and telemarketing sales, Commerce Commission
- Romance scams, Netsafe
Checked 21 November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.




