Skip to content
Join free

Selective Search review: cost, process and who it suits

A Chicago matchmaking firm that runs searches like executive recruitment and publishes its price range. Here's what it says, checked on 21 November 2026.

By the Dating Agency editorial teamUpdated · 3 min read

In short

Selective Search is a Chicago-based matchmaking firm founded in 2000. Its pricing page says a retained search typically costs $50,000 to $500,000, set after a free consultation. Its candidate programme is free: you're contacted only if you fit a paying client. Ask how many introductions a search includes.

Key facts
What it isExecutive-search-style matchmaking
Published priceTypically $50,000 to $500,000
Free optionCandidate programme
Checked on21 November 2026

Selective Search is a Chicago-based matchmaking firm, founded in 2000 by Barbie Adler, that runs its searches like executive recruitment. It is one of the few luxury firms to publish a price range, and it runs a free programme for people who'd like to be considered for its clients.

This is a desk review: we read what Selective Search says on its own website on 21 November 2026. We didn't join, pay or test its matching, we don't quote customer reviews, and it doesn't pay to appear.

Selective Search at a glance

Item What it says or what we found
What it is Retained, executive-search-style matchmaking
Founded 2000
Where Chicago head office; clients and candidates across the US and Canada
Published price A retained search typically $50,000 to $500,000
Free option Candidate programme: no fee to join or to be matched
Process Its six-step Meet Your Future process

How it works

Clients go through what it calls its Meet Your Future process: a confidential intake consultation, then searching, screening and introductions to people it calls "must-meet" candidates, with a dedicated matchmaker and a team of researchers. It says it assesses more than 225 personal, professional and social compatibility indicators. Clients sign a defined contract rather than a subscription. People who don't want to pay can join its candidate programme: you complete a confidential profile, and its matchmakers contact you only if they find a two-way fit with a client.

What it costs

Its pricing page says a retained search typically costs $50,000 to $500,000, depending on the scope and complexity of the search, and that highly complex searches may reach seven figures. The price is set after a free consultation in which a firm executive defines the scope. The candidate programme is free.

What its pages don't say

We didn't find, on the pages we read, how many introductions a search includes, how long it runs, or what happens if you end it early. It publishes success figures; ask how they're measured. If you join as a candidate, remember that the people you meet are paying clients and the search is built around their criteria.

Your rights in the US

Your rights depend on your state, not the firm. California, New York, Illinois, Arizona and Colorado, among others, have laws written for dating services, typically with a three-business-day cancellation period and limits on contract length or payments; in states such as Massachusetts and Texas we found no dating service law, so the contract decides. Our guide to dating agencies in the US sets out the state rules we've checked. Get the contract in writing and read the cancellation clause before you pay.

Who it may suit

Selective Search suits people who can afford a five- or six-figure retained search and want a firm to recruit for them. The candidate programme suits anyone who'd like to be introduced to its clients at no cost, as long as they accept that they may never be contacted.

Questions to ask before you pay

  1. What is the full fee, including tax, and what does each level add?
  2. How many introductions will I get, over what period, and what counts as one?
  3. How many current members fit what I'm looking for, and where do they live?
  4. Are my matches paying clients, free candidates or people you'll headhunt?
  5. What checks do you run on identity and relationship status?
  6. Can I pause my membership, and what happens to the fee if I leave early?
  7. Can I take the contract away to read before I sign?

At this price, also ask: who exactly is searching for me, how will they recruit, and what reports will I get along the way?

Our full list of questions and warning signs when choosing an agency have more.

We read Selective Search's pricing, matchmaking services, client services, candidate programme, FAQs, process and local pages. Selective Search's own current documents take precedence over our summary.

Our own online service, listed separately

DatingAgency.com is not an agency and has no relationship with the firm reviewed here. We run an online dating service where you do the searching yourself: nobody interviews members or picks matches. Joining, making a profile and browsing are free; reading and replying to messages needs a paid membership that renews until you cancel. How our service works and our prices give the details.

Join Dating Agency free

Free to join and browse. Reading and replying to messages is paid.

Questions people ask

How much does Selective Search cost?

Its pricing page says a retained search typically costs $50,000 to $500,000, depending on scope and complexity, and that very complex searches can reach seven figures. The price is set after a free consultation.

Is Selective Search free for some people?

Yes. Its candidate programme has no fees to join or to be matched. You complete a confidential profile, and its matchmakers contact you only if they find a two-way fit with one of its paying clients.

Where does Selective Search operate?

Its head office is in Chicago, and it has local pages for many US cities as well as Toronto and Vancouver.

Is Selective Search worth it?

That depends on the scope of your search, what the contract promises and whether you can afford the fee without needing it back. Get the number of introductions and the exit terms in writing.

Keep reading

All of Reviews

On this page
  1. Selective Search at a glance
  2. How it works
  3. What it costs
  4. What its pages don't say
  5. Your rights in the US
  6. Who it may suit
  7. Questions to ask before you pay
  8. How we reviewed Selective Search
  9. Our own online service, listed separately

Dating Agency

Hello. Who are you hoping to meet?

Hello. Who are you hoping to meet?

Thank you. Add your email and we will set up your free profile.

Prefer a form?