Skip to content
Join free

US matchmaking services, compared by how they work

Seven matchmakers working in US cities, grouped by the kind of service they sell, using only what each says on its own website, checked on 21 November 2026. No firm paid to be listed.

By the Dating Agency editorial teamUpdated · 4 min read

In short

US matchmakers fall into three groups: date-arranging services such as It's Just Lunch and Tawkify, matchmaker-led memberships such as Three Day Rule, and luxury retained searches such as Kelleher International and Selective Search. Only Selective Search publishes a price, a retained search averaging $50,000 to $500,000. Several states, including New York and California, give you three business days to cancel.

Key facts
Services compared7, each checked on its own website
Publishing a priceSelective Search only: $50,000 to $500,000 on average
Joining as a candidate4 of 7 let you join their pool of possible matches without being a client
Cancel without a fee3 business days in California, New York, Illinois and Arizona
Checked on21 November 2026

American matchmaking ranges from services that book you a lunch date with someone they've screened to retained searches for executives with a dedicated team. Only one of the big names publishes a price range, so comparing them on cost alone isn't possible. What you can compare is how each one works, who it's for and what it says about screening.

How we chose and compared

We included matchmakers that work in more than one major US city, plus one firm based in Los Angeles (Matchmakers In The City), whose own websites explain how the service works. For each, we recorded where it operates, how it describes its process and screening, whether it publishes a price, and whether you can join as a candidate rather than a client, all from its own pages on 21 November 2026. We didn't join any service or test its matching, and none paid to appear. Where a firm doesn't publish a price, we say so rather than guess. City-by-city detail is in our New York and Los Angeles guides. We've also written desk reviews of Tawkify, Three Day Rule and Kelleher International, which go through each firm's published terms.

At a glance

Service Where it works Published price Screening it describes Join as a candidate
It's Just Lunch US cities (choose yours on its site), since 1991 No Interview with a matchmaker Not stated
Tawkify Every state, mostly big cities No; trial of 3 or 6 matches Criminal record and video screening Yes, as a member
Three Day Rule 15 named US cities plus nationwide No; free consultation Face-to-face vetting Yes, free database
Matchmakers In The City Beverly Hills based No Interviews and background checks Not stated
Modern Love Club New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco No Interviews Yes ("Rolodex")
Kelleher International San Francisco head office; LA, New York, Dallas, Miami and more No Acceptance process, pre-screened matches Not stated
Selective Search Chicago head office, clients nationwide Yes: $50,000 to $500,000 on average Candidates screened like clients Yes, candidate programme

Dates arranged for you

It's Just Lunch sets up lunch or after-work dates for busy professionals and books the time and place. It says it has run since 1991 and guarantees face-to-face dates, and you can pause your membership if a match goes well. It describes its fees as sitting between dating apps and high-end matchmakers.

Tawkify gives you a dedicated matchmaker and plans each date. It says it works in every state, that most clients are 30 to 65, and that it runs criminal record and video screening on every candidate. Packages depend on the features and number of matches, and you can start with three or six matches. Its site warns that it never asks for payment by Cash App, Zelle, gift cards or cryptocurrency.

Matchmaker-led memberships

Three Day Rule has pages for 15 cities, including New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Boston and Seattle. Its matchmakers vet each potential match face to face, and it offers a free consultation, a premium membership and a free database for people not ready to pay.

Matchmakers In The City is based in Beverly Hills and was founded about 14 years ago by two sisters. Its in-person memberships include interviewed and background-checked matches, date planning, feedback meetings and date coaching.

Modern Love Club, founded by Amy Van Doran, starts with an hour-long consultation and then proposes a plan, with coaching included in its matchmaking package. Anyone can create a private "Rolodex" profile to be considered for clients.

Luxury retained searches

Kelleher International works with senior professionals and describes a stringent acceptance process, pre-screened matches and no online profiles. It has local lines in Los Angeles and New York City and a global office in San Francisco.

Selective Search, founded in 2000 by Barbie Adler, runs a retained search model; its pricing page says a search averages $50,000 to $500,000, depending on scope, under a defined contract rather than a subscription. It also runs a candidate programme for people who don't want a client membership. Its application asks for your annual income.

What the law says before you sign

There's no federal law written for matchmakers, but several states have one. California, New York, Illinois and Arizona all give you three business days to cancel a dating service contract. New York also caps most social referral contracts at $1,000 and two years and requires a set number of referrals each month; California limits payments to two years and lets you stop paying if you move more than 50 miles away. Our guide to US matchmaker and dating service laws explains each state's rules. We're not lawyers, so take advice if a large sum is at stake.

What the fee should buy

Whatever you're quoted, get these in writing: how many introductions, over what period and within what distance; whether matches are paying clients, candidates or people headhunted for you; what checks are run; whether you can pause; and how you cancel. Questions to ask a dating agency has the full list, and is a matchmaker worth it? helps you weigh the money.

Our own online service, listed separately

DatingAgency.com is not one of the services above. We run an online dating service where you do the searching yourself: nobody interviews members or picks matches. Joining, making a profile and browsing are free; reading and replying to messages needs a paid membership that renews until you cancel. US members pay in dollars. Profiles are shared with partner sites in the same network, and what members write about themselves isn't checked. How our service works and our prices give the details, and the same safety advice applies.

Join Dating Agency free

Free to join and browse. Reading and replying to messages is paid.

Questions people ask

What is the best matchmaking service in the US?

There isn't one best service for everyone. The right one depends on your budget, your city and how much of the search you want done for you. Compare who is in each network, how matches are screened, what counts as an introduction and the cancellation terms, and meet the matchmaker before you pay.

How much does a matchmaker cost in the US?

Only Selective Search publishes a figure: its pricing page says a retained search averages $50,000 to $500,000, depending on scope. Tawkify says its packages depend on features and the number of matches, and the others quote at a consultation. New York caps most social referral contracts at $1,000, so New York clients should ask how a higher quote fits the law.

Can I join a matchmaker without paying?

Sometimes, as a candidate rather than a client. Three Day Rule says its database of potential matches is free, and Tawkify, Selective Search and Modern Love Club also let people join their pool to be considered for paying clients; ask whether there is any charge. Nobody searches on your behalf, but you may be introduced to someone.

Do US matchmakers run background checks?

Some say so. Tawkify says it runs criminal record and video screening on every candidate, and Matchmakers In The City says its matches are background checked. Others describe interviews and screening in general terms, so ask exactly what each check covers.

Does DatingAgency.com run a matchmaking service?

No. DatingAgency.com runs its own online dating service, listed separately on this page, and writes independent guides. No matchmaker pays to appear in our comparisons.

Keep reading

On this page
  1. How we chose and compared
  2. At a glance
  3. Dates arranged for you
  4. Matchmaker-led memberships
  5. Luxury retained searches
  6. What the law says before you sign
  7. What the fee should buy
  8. Our own online service, listed separately

Dating Agency

Hello. Who are you hoping to meet?

Hello. Who are you hoping to meet?

Thank you. Add your email and we will set up your free profile.

Prefer a form?