In short
We checked six matchmakers covering New York City on 21 November 2026. Only Selective Search publishes a price, averaging $50,000 to $500,000 for a retained search. New York's Dating Service Law caps most social referral contracts at $1,000 and two years and gives you three business days to cancel, so ask how a firm's contract fits. DatingAgency.com is not an agency.
| Firms listed | 6, each checked on its own website |
|---|---|
| Publishing a price | Selective Search only: $50,000 to $500,000 on average |
| Cancel without a fee | 3 business days after you receive the contract (New York law) |
| Price cap | $1,000 and 2 years for most social referral contracts; online services can be exempt |
| Checked on | 21 November 2026 |
New York has more matchmakers than almost anywhere, from national firms with a Manhattan phone line to boutique services that meet clients over coffee. Only one publishes a price, and most draw on networks well beyond the five boroughs, so the useful questions are who is in the network, how they're screened and what the contract promises.
Below are six services that say on their own websites that they cover New York City, what each publishes, and where each stays silent. Everything comes from each firm's own pages as they read on 21 November 2026, and its own documents take precedence over our summary. No listing is paid for and none carries an affiliate link.
Who's working in New York right now
Three Day Rule (New York City page)
Three Day Rule's New York page says it searches across all five boroughs and that its matchmakers vet each potential match face to face. It offers a free consultation and a premium membership, and lets people who aren't ready to pay join its free database of potential matches. It also covers more than a dozen other US cities. It doesn't publish prices.
Kelleher International (New York City line, San Francisco head office)
A high-end matchmaker for professionals, with a New York City page and phone line, 1-212-244-1514. Its global office is in San Francisco, and it lists Los Angeles, New York City, Dallas and Miami among its locations. It describes a stringent acceptance process, pre-screened matches and detailed interviews, and says it doesn't use online profiles. It doesn't publish prices.
Modern Love Club (New York City, Los Angeles and beyond)
A boutique service founded by Amy Van Doran, which says it serves New York City, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Mexico City and Europe. You start with an hour-long first consultation, the "Love Session", with a matchmaker; if both sides want to go ahead it proposes a plan. Coaching is included in its matchmaking package, and it speaks to your match after a first date to collect feedback. Anyone can create a private profile in its "Rolodex" to be considered for clients. It doesn't publish prices on the pages we read.
Tawkify (national)
Tawkify says it works with clients in every state, with more in and around big cities, and that most clients are 30 to 65. You get a dedicated matchmaker, an onboarding call of about an hour, and dates it plans for you. Its FAQ says it runs criminal record screening and video screening on every candidate. It doesn't publish prices: packages depend on the features and the number of matches, and you can start with three or six matches to try it. It separates paying clients from members, who sit in its candidate pool and may be matched with clients but don't get a matchmaker. Its site warns that it never asks for payment by Cash App, Zelle, gift cards or cryptocurrency.
It's Just Lunch (national, since 1991)
It's Just Lunch arranges lunch or after-work dates for busy professionals and books the time and place for you. It says it has run since 1991 and guarantees face-to-face dates. You can put your membership on hold if a match goes well. It doesn't publish prices, describing itself as between dating apps and high-end matchmakers. Its site asks you to choose your city, so ask which office would handle your membership.
Selective Search (national, Chicago head office)
A luxury matchmaking firm founded in 2000 by Barbie Adler, with clients and candidates across the country and an office on Wacker Drive, Chicago. Clients pay for a retained search under a defined contract; its pricing page says one averages $50,000 to $500,000, depending on scope. People who don't want a client membership can apply to its candidate programme instead, to be considered for clients. Its application form asks for your annual income.
Prices: what each one publishes
| Firm | Published price | What it says instead | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Three Day Rule | Not published | Free consultation; a free database for people not ready to pay | 21 Nov 2026 |
| Kelleher International | Not published | Membership after an acceptance process | 21 Nov 2026 |
| Modern Love Club | Not published | An hour-long first consultation, then a tailored proposal | 21 Nov 2026 |
| Tawkify | Not published | Price depends on features and number of matches; trial of 3 or 6 matches | 21 Nov 2026 |
| It's Just Lunch | Not published | Fee-based, between apps and high-end matchmakers | 21 Nov 2026 |
| Selective Search | A retained search averages $50,000 to $500,000 | Price set by scope at a consultation | 21 Nov 2026 |
Several of these firms let you join their pool of possible matches without becoming a client; Three Day Rule says its database is free. That can be a low-cost way to meet people, but you're the candidate, not the client: nobody is searching on your behalf.
What New York law says
New York's Dating Service Law (General Business Law section 394-c) covers any fee-based service matching people for dating or social contact. In short:
- Price and length. The cash price can't exceed $1,000, and the service can't run beyond two years. Online dating services can be exempt from the cap if each term is a year or less.
- Referrals each month. A contract costing more than $25 must say how many referrals you'll get each month. Miss them two months running and you can cancel for a refund, less a fee of no more than 15% of the price or a pro rata amount.
- Pausing. You can put your membership on hold for up to a year.
- Cancelling. You have three business days to cancel without a fee, by certified or registered mail.
- No forced extras. You can't be required to buy photography, coaching or other add-ons to join.
We can't tell from a website how a firm's contract handles these rules, so ask, and read the contract before you sign. Our guide to US matchmaker and dating service laws sets out the rest, and the state Attorney General publishes a Dating Service Consumer Bill of Rights. We're not lawyers, so take advice if a large sum is at stake.
How each one screens the people you'll meet
- Tawkify. Criminal record screening and video screening for every candidate, by its own account.
- Three Day Rule. Says its matchmakers vet each potential match face to face.
- Kelleher International. Describes pre-screened matches and detailed interviews.
- Modern Love Club, It's Just Lunch and Selective Search. Describe interviews and screening in general terms; ask what checks are actually run.
Our desk reviews of Tawkify, Three Day Rule and Kelleher International go through each firm's published terms on refunds, renewals and referrals.
A background check confirms some facts about a person. It doesn't confirm that everything they told the matchmaker is true. Our guide to how agencies vet members explains what to ask.
What to ask at your first consultation
Take these to any matchmaker in New York, and ask for the answers in writing:
- What is the full fee, and what does each package include?
- How many introductions will I get, over what period, and does a match I decline count as one?
- Are my matches paying clients, people in your free database, or people you headhunt?
- How many current members fit what I'm looking for, and how far away do they live?
- What checks do you run on matches: ID, criminal records, relationship status?
- Can I pause my membership, and what happens if you run out of suitable people?
- How do I cancel, and what would I get back?
Our full list of questions works for US matchmakers too, and warning signs when choosing an agency covers the pressure tactics to walk away from.
When a matchmaker isn't the answer
A matchmaker makes most sense if you're short of time, want people screened before you meet them, and can afford to lose the fee if it doesn't work out. It makes less sense on a tight budget, or if you'd rather see who's out there yourself. Be cautious with anyone who presses you to sign at the first meeting, suggests financing the fee, or won't let you take the contract home.
If something goes wrong
Start with the firm, in writing, then escalate.
| Problem | Where to go |
|---|---|
| The firm won't cancel or refund | Write to it citing your contract and the Dating Service Law; then the New York State Attorney General on 1-800-771-7755 or online |
| You paid by credit card and the service wasn't provided | Your card issuer: ask about a billing dispute |
| An introduction asks you for money | Don't pay; tell the firm, then report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and, if it happened online, to the FBI's IC3 |
| You feel unsafe | Leave, and call 911 |
Our own online service, listed separately
DatingAgency.com is not one of the services above. We run an online dating service where you do the searching yourself: nobody interviews members or picks matches. Joining, making a profile and browsing are free; reading and replying to messages needs a paid membership that renews until you cancel. US members pay in dollars. Profiles are shared with partner sites in the same network, and what members write about themselves isn't checked. How our service works and our prices give the details, and the same safety advice applies.
Join Dating Agency free
Free to join and browse. Reading and replying to messages is paid.
Questions people ask
How much does a matchmaker cost in New York?
Only Selective Search publishes a figure: its pricing page says a retained search averages $50,000 to $500,000, depending on scope. Tawkify says packages depend on features and the number of matches, and the others quote at a consultation. New York's Dating Service Law caps the cash price of most social referral contracts at $1,000, so ask any firm quoting more how its contract fits the law.
Can I cancel a matchmaking contract in New York?
Yes. New York law gives you three business days after you receive the written contract to cancel without a fee, by certified or registered mail to the address in the contract. The refund is due within 10 business days. Our guide to US dating service laws has the details.
Do New York matchmakers do background checks?
Some say so. Tawkify says it runs criminal record and video screening on every candidate, Three Day Rule says it vets each match face to face, and Kelleher International describes pre-screened matches. Ask exactly what each check covers before you pay.
What is the best matchmaker in New York?
We don't rank matchmakers: nobody can test them fairly without being a client of each. Compare them on who is in their network, how they screen people, what counts as an introduction, the full fee and the cancellation terms, and get each answer in writing.
Is DatingAgency.com a matchmaker?
No. We are not an agency and nobody here picks matches. Our online dating service is listed separately below, labelled as ours.
Keep reading
- Dating agencies and matchmakers in Newcastle and the North EastIntroduction services covering Newcastle compared from their own websites: prices, vetting and contract terms.
- Dating agencies and matchmakers in Nottingham and the East MidlandsThree services covering Nottingham, Derby and Leicester compared from their own websites: prices, vetting and contract terms.
- Dating agencies and matchmakers in Oxford and OxfordshireIntroduction services covering Oxford compared from their own websites: prices, vetting and contract terms.
- Perth dating agencies and matchmakers: who's who and what it costsFour agencies and matchmakers serving Perth compared: offices, published AUD prices, how they vet members and their terms.
Sources
- New York City, Three Day Rule (checked 21 November 2026)
- What we offer, Three Day Rule (checked 21 November 2026)
- FAQ, Tawkify (checked 21 November 2026)
- How it works, Tawkify (checked 21 November 2026)
- Our process and FAQ, It's Just Lunch (checked 21 November 2026)
- Membership, Kelleher International (checked 21 November 2026)
- Pricing, Selective Search (checked 21 November 2026)
- Client program, Selective Search (checked 21 November 2026)
- FAQ, Selective Search (checked 21 November 2026)
- Modern Love Club (checked 21 November 2026)
- Become a client, Modern Love Club (checked 21 November 2026)
- New York City matchmaking, Kelleher International (checked 21 November 2026)
- New York General Business Law section 394-c (text as published by New York Public Law)
- Dating Service Consumer Bill of Rights, New York State Attorney General
- File a consumer complaint, New York State Attorney General
- Report fraud, Federal Trade Commission
- Internet Crime Complaint Center (FBI)
Checked 21 November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.




